AM Online

Sytner BMW parts manager avoids jail over £62,000 refund scam


A Sytner Group BMW parts manager has avoided jail after he admitted defrauding the top AM100 car retail group of £62,000 in a refund scam.

Richard Aston (aged 37), of Langford Avenue, Great Barr, paid refunds into the bank accounts of a friend, his brother-in-law and his wife, during a year of offending between March 2018 and 2019, Birmingham Live reported.

Prosecutor Darron Whitehead told Birmingham Crown Court that Aston had worked at Sytner BMW Birmingham as a parts supervisor since 2008 but gained responsibility for managing employees, stock control and authorising refunds when he was promoted in 2015.

An internal investigation later uncovered screenshots – captured by a work colleague – in which Aston which alluded to his “admission of guilt” and “acknowledgement of how much money he had taken”, the court heard.

Aston pleaded guilty to a charge of fraud by abuse of position.

Birmingham Live reported that Mukhtiar Ubhi, mitigating, had said that his client had been battling mental health issues had called for a psychological assessment.

But no further mitigation was offered after Judge Roderick Henderson indicated he would not be sending Aston to prison immediately.

Judge Henderson described Aston as a person of previous good character who had “worked for a significant time honestly”, adding: “If there is a case for a suspended sentence, this is it.”

Aston was handed two-year jail sentence suspended for the same period, ordered to repay the full £62,320 and also carry out 30 days of rehabilitation and 120 hours of unpaid work.

The latest AM industry special issue

There has never been such desire for management information, for on-the-spot monitoring, for streamlining and automation, as there is now.

With this in mind, AM asked suppliers of some of the critical technologies dealers can use in their businesses, whether at the front end or in back-of-house functions, to share their latest developments and technologies for the AM Dealer Technology Guide.


Read now

If you are not a registered user your comment will go to AM for approval before publishing. To avoid this requirement please register or login.

Login to comment


No comments have been made yet.